Analysis

Six saves and a stoppage-time double stop in Madrid: the keeper Man City sold in the summer reopens Maresca’s Donnarumma debate

James Trafford Man City

Six saves, a stoppage-time double stop and a win in Madrid: James Trafford has just given Man City fans a very awkward question to chew on over the last few days of the international break.

The 24-year-old started ahead of Jordan Pickford as England beat Spain 3-2 at the Metropolitano on Sunday, ending Spain’s 43-game unbeaten run. Trafford was the reason England held on after going down to ten men.

Back at the Etihad, Gianluigi Donnarumma has had an up-and-down start to the season, mixing outstanding saves with mistakes that have cost City points. So the summer call to let Trafford go, a year after bringing him back, is being argued about all over again.

What did Trafford do against Spain?

James Trafford was given the gloves by Thomas Tuchel, and England were 3-0 up early in the second half through Harry Kane’s penalty, Ezri Konsa and Ben White. Then the game turned on a Man City player.

Elliot Anderson was sent off in the 63rd minute for bringing down Lamine Yamal in the box, and Mikel Oyarzabal scored the penalty. Nico Williams made it 3-2 with 15 minutes left, and from there England spent most of the evening defending their own box.

Trafford stopped a long-range effort from Yamal on 79 minutes and Marc Cucurella’s near-post strike seconds later. In stoppage time he saved from Fermín López and recovered to deny Aymeric Laporte. Six saves in all, and the last two won the game.

Tuchel was careful not to crown him. “There’s no ‘No.1’,” the England boss said, before adding: “It’s a good double save. That’s exactly what we wanted and he had a brilliant match.” He also said: “We need to see Trafford in high-pressure moments.” Madrid was exactly that.

Why did Man City let him go?

Trafford came back to Manchester as the first choice and talked about becoming number one for club and country. Within weeks, Pep Guardiola had signed Donnarumma and Trafford was the cup keeper. He did that job well, too, as City won both the Carabao Cup and the FA Cup with him in goal.

It wasn’t enough for a keeper who wanted to play every week, and he left for Leeds United in the summer. Maresca and the club didn’t stand in his way. He has hit the ground running in Yorkshire, and he was open about how hard life on the bench had been after shutting out Spurs earlier this month.

Maresca explained the exit earlier this season: “There are players that unfortunately, like James last year, didn’t play a lot and at the end they work every day to get minutes and to play games and when they don’t play it’s normal that they are sad and want to play more games and that was probably the case with James.”

He added: “The club was happy with him, everyone was happy with him, but at the end he was probably looking for more games.”

Is Donnarumma still Maresca’s number one?

Yes, and nothing suggests that is about to change. Maresca’s line is that, in this moment, it is “Gigio plus 10”, and the 27-year-old will be in goal when City return against Fulham this weekend.

The Italian has a CV few keepers in the world can match, but this season has been patchy. It was the same story with Italy during the break, where he went into the France game with San Siro jeering him.

The timing doesn’t help. City went into the break on three straight domestic defeats and six points off Arsenal, with Fulham, Napoli in the Champions League and then Arsenal at the Emirates to come. A goalkeeper error in that run would cost far more than one bad afternoon.

Trafford vs Donnarumma: the answer comes on 2 December

Leeds visit the Etihad on Wednesday 2 December, so City will see the keeper they sold up close. Leeds have conceded only eight Premier League goals this season, and Trafford has a lot to do with that.

Our view: City weren’t wrong to sell. Trafford wanted to play, a cup keeper’s role was never going to keep him, and two trophies from that role was a fair return. The real question is whether Donnarumma is still the right number one, and that has nothing to do with Trafford. If the Italian cuts out the errors, Sunday’s heroics in Madrid are just a nice story about a former City keeper. If he doesn’t, every Trafford clean sheet will feel like a dig at the Etihad, and the loudest one could come on 2 December.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To Top