Analysis

Premier League asks every club to cover Masters if Man City’s sponsors sue, and 14 votes will decide it

Enzo-Maresca-Man-City.

The Premier League has asked all 20 of its clubs to stand behind chief executive Richard Masters and four other directors if Manchester City’s sponsors take them to court, over cases that could end up costing billions.

According to The Times, Masters and his four fellow directors want the clubs to protect them personally and to cover any legal bills, which could run into hundreds of millions of pounds. The clubs will consider the request at a meeting this week, and it needs a majority of 14 to pass.

It is a remarkable thing for a league’s own board to ask for. It also tells City fans something about how seriously the people who brought the case are taking the threat from Abu Dhabi.

Who could sue the Premier League?

Two names sit at the centre of this. Etihad Airways, City’s principal sponsor since 2009, said at the start of October that it was considering legal action against the Premier League. The airline said it “categorically rejects any finding, conclusion or implication” that it was part of improper arrangements, and that it would “seek the relevant legal counsel” to protect its interests.

Etisalat is described as watching closely. Both companies are said to be waiting for the league to publish the full Manchester City judgment before they decide what to do next.

That detail matters. Insiders suggest the Premier League may have held back publication because its directors do not yet have legal protection. In other words, the league is not keen to put the full findings out until somebody has agreed to pay if those findings end up in court.

Why personal cover for Masters and the directors?

The request is not only about the league as a company. The worry is that sponsors could go after the five directors as individuals. If that happens, they want the clubs, the league’s shareholders, to stand behind them.

For the 19 clubs who are not City, that is an awkward vote. Backing the board means signing up to bills that could reach a scale no club has ever had to think about. Refusing it would leave the people who ran the case on their own, and make publishing the full judgment even less likely.

We would expect a majority to back the board. The bigger question is how many clubs, if any, hesitate, because that would show how united the league really is now the verdict is in and the bills are starting to arrive.

Where the Man City case stands now

In September, an independent commission found City guilty on 114 of the 115 charges brought in 2023. It ruled that the club used “sham” sponsorship deals as part of a disguised funding scheme that inflated revenue by £830million between 2009-10 and 2017-18, and that City did not cooperate with the investigation in good faith. City deny the findings and have called them “unsafe”.

City lodged their appeal on October 1, and the appeal is now expected to be heard in mid-December, with the Appeal Board’s findings due in the New Year. A decision on sanctions would only follow if City lose, so any punishment is not expected until 2027.

That is why the timing of this vote is so interesting. The sponsors are not waiting for the appeal. They are waiting for the full written judgment, and that is a separate decision in the league’s hands.

What about the sponsorship rules fight?

This is a different fight from City’s old battle over the associated party transaction (APT) rules, which cover deals with companies linked to a club’s owners. That dispute ended in September 2025, when City and the league settled and City accepted that the current APT rules are valid and binding.

So the legal threat now comes from outside the club. Etihad and Etisalat are not bound by the Premier League rulebook in the way City are, and that is exactly what makes them dangerous to Masters and his board.

What it means for City on the pitch

Very little in the short term. Enzo Maresca has kept saying his squad can only control the football, and City return against Fulham on Saturday after the international break. Nothing in this week’s meeting changes the appeal timetable or brings a sanction any closer.

What it does do is add another layer of noise. The longer the full judgment stays unpublished, the longer every new report about it, and every complaint from rival clubs about how slowly the case has moved, lands on Maresca’s desk.

Verdict: the Man City sponsors now hold the cards

For years this was a straight fight between City and the league. Now the league’s own directors want insurance before the full story is made public, and that is a sign of how big they think the sponsors’ threat could be.

In our view, the clubs will back Masters, but the vote should not be read as a show of strength. If the board needs 14 clubs to promise to pay before it will publish a ruling it won, then Etihad and Etisalat have already changed the way this case ends.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To Top