Analysis

74% of fans want Man City’s £125m record signing dropped for Fulham, and the break hands Maresca a reason to do it

Enzo Fernandez Manchester City

Enzo Maresca has one big call to make before Manchester City host Fulham on Saturday: does Enzo Fernandez keep his place next to Elliot Anderson, or is it finally Ayyoub Bouaddi’s turn?

City went into the international break on the back of three straight league defeats, to Aston Villa, Brighton and Nottingham Forest, after winning their first seven. They sit third, six points behind Arsenal, and the next two weeks bring Fulham at the Etihad on 21 November (12.30pm UK) and then a trip to the Emirates on 29 November.

The break gives Maresca time to look hard at his midfield. In our view it is the area that decides whether City get back to the side that started the season, and the one where the answer is least obvious.

Why the Man City midfield is the problem

It is not that City have stopped having the ball. They had 79 per cent possession at the City Ground and still lost 3-1. They have kept no clean sheet in nine games, and Maresca admitted his side could not match Forest’s intensity in the first half.

The trouble is what happens when City lose it. Maresca pushes a full-back high to make a line of five around Erling Haaland, which brings goals but leaves big spaces in the middle on the turnover. Rodri used to close those gaps before anyone noticed them. Since he left for Barcelona in the summer, that job has fallen mostly on Elliot Anderson.

Anderson has been City’s best summer signing so far and is an automatic pick. But he is one man, and in the last three games he has too often been left to cover the middle alone.

The case for keeping Enzo Fernandez

Fernandez is City’s record signing at £125million, and Maresca wanted him as a player who already knows his demands from their time together at Chelsea. He keeps the ball moving, he finds passes through the lines, and he gives City a second playmaker when teams sit deep, which Fulham may well do at the Etihad.

Dropping him would also be a big statement this early in his City career. Managers do not often bench their most expensive player after three bad results, and Maresca has stood by senior players in public before, as he has with Gianluigi Donnarumma.

And the case against

The form is hard to defend. He was given a 4 in our ratings after the Forest defeat, having headed over City’s best first-half chance, and then lost at home with Argentina against Uruguay before telling reporters his side had “controlled the game from start to finish”.

More importantly, his game does not fix the problem City have. In the last few weeks he has played much higher and freer, with little defensive work, and that leaves Anderson exposed. Supporters have noticed: a fan poll this week found 74 per cent want him left out against Fulham, with just 18 per cent keeping him in.

Is Ayyoub Bouaddi ready to start?

The 19-year-old has made 10 appearances in all competitions since joining from Lille, but only two Premier League starts. He is a natural holding midfielder, calm on the ball and good at winning it back, which is exactly the profile City have been missing next to Anderson.

He has already done it on a big night. Coming in for Anderson in Porto in the Champions League, he helped City to an away win, and Maresca said afterwards: “I didn’t see him panic.” Our Ayyoub Bouaddi scouting report goes into how he plays and why he has not yet held a place.

The risk is experience. Bouaddi is still new to English football, and a Premier League game against Fulham is not the same as a one-off in Europe. But Fulham at home, with a full week of training first, is probably the gentlest test City will get before Arsenal.

What about Kovacic?

Mateo Kovacic is the experienced option, but he has played in only three league games all season and can agree a move abroad in January. It would be a surprise if Maresca turned to him now.

Fernandez or Bouaddi against Fulham?

Several of the players involved are away with their countries, so Maresca will not have everyone back until late in the week. Fernandez is one of them, and he still has Argentina’s game against Costa Rica to come.

That matters. The players left in Manchester get more time with the coaching staff, and the manager has time to work on the shape without the ball, especially the gap between the defence and the front line that opponents have kept finding.

Verdict: Bouaddi has earned his chance in the Man City midfield

We would start Bouaddi alongside Anderson against Fulham and move Fernandez into a role nearer the attack, or onto the bench for one game. It is not about blaming one player. City need someone whose first thought is protecting the centre, and right now that is the teenager.

Get the balance right on Saturday and City go to the Emirates with a midfield that can stand up to Arsenal. Keep the same three and hope, and Maresca risks finding out at the worst possible moment that the break changed nothing.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To Top