Phil Foden has not started a Premier League game for Manchester City since 17 October, and with Fulham at the Etihad on Saturday, the former Player of the Season is facing the most uncertain spell of his career without Pep Guardiola.
On the face of it, his season has had a lift. A hat-trick in the Champions League, a first league goal of the campaign and a manager who says it is his “duty” to get the best out of him. But look at the Premier League alone and the picture is very different.
Former England striker Darren Bent has gone further, saying he is “worried” about Foden and wondering whether a move away from City might be the only way for him to find his best again.
Phil Foden’s season so far
It started badly. Phil Foden was sent off 23 minutes into the Manchester derby at Old Trafford, a red card that kept him out of league football for nearly a month. City won the game, but he had to watch the next few from the stands.
The comeback was quick. He scored his first Premier League goal of the season against Ipswich Town on 17 October, then followed it with a hat-trick and an assist in a 5-1 Champions League win over AEK Athens. Four goals in two games, and suddenly the talk was of an England recall.
Then the door closed again. He was left on the bench for the trip to Aston Villa and came on at half-time for Rayan Cherki, with Maresca explaining: “Today we needed a technical midfielder, that’s why Rayan was out and Phil was inside.” By the international break he had made eight Premier League appearances this season, and that Ipswich game remained his last league start.
What Foden says about his form
Foden himself sounded positive before the win in Leipzig earlier this month. He said: “I had the unfortunate red card against United. But the break did me good. I think I came back really fresh-minded and sharp. Being involved in goals gives you a lot of confidence. When you’re playing regularly as well, you kind of just get into a rhythm and a groove.”
He knows where the bar is. In 2023-24 he scored 27 goals in all competitions and was named the Premier League’s Player of the Season and the PFA Player of the Year. That fell to 13 the following season and 10 last season. “Hopefully I can get back to that level,” he said. “I think I’m slightly starting to get back there now with my recent performances.”
He also admitted he has not spoken to Thomas Tuchel since being left out of England’s World Cup squad, and he was not in the latest England squad either: “All I try and do really is focus on my own game and hopefully one day the call-up might come back.”
Why Darren Bent is worried
Bent’s concern is not really about form. It is about what Foden is without Guardiola. “I’m worried about Foden full stop,” he said. “My conversations were always, I wonder what Foden looks like when Pep’s no longer there. Because his whole football education has been Pep Guardiola.”
He pointed to England as the warning sign: “When he played for Man City, he was top, top drawer, top level, one of the best about. But every single time he played for England, we never saw that same Phil Foden.”
And then the line City fans will not want to read: “So the fact Pep’s not there and now he’s not playing for Manchester City and now he’s not in the England squad, I just wonder if potentially a move away from City might be best for Phil Foden to almost start again and kind of re-find himself.”
Does Maresca still trust him?
Everything Maresca has said in public suggests yes. In October he explained that he sat down with Foden two or three times after taking over to show him how important he is, adding: “For different reasons, the last few years he was not good enough but I think when you have players like Phil available you are a better team because it’s a matter of improving players. For me, it’s my duty to try to help him to be one of the best players in England again.”
The problem is the competition. Enzo Fernandez, Cherki and Iliman Ndiaye have all been ahead of him for league games, and Foden signed a new contract in the summer that runs to 2030, with an option for another year, so City are not short of time to sort it out. He has made 378 appearances for the club since his debut at 17, and has won six Premier League titles, the FA Cup, the League Cup and the Champions League.
The midfield debate before Fulham has mostly been about whether Fernandez keeps his place. In our Man City predicted lineup vs Fulham, Foden is among the options from the bench.
Verdict: Foden does not need a new club, he needs a run
Bent has a point about Guardiola. Nobody knew how to use Foden better, and every manager who follows will be judged against that. But the idea that a 26-year-old who scored four goals in two games last month needs to leave City feels a long way ahead of the evidence.
What Foden needs is what he said himself: to play regularly and get into a rhythm. City have 13 games in 46 days, starting with Fulham on Saturday, and three straight league defeats mean nobody’s place is safe. If Maresca really believes it is his duty to make Foden one of the best players in England again, this run of fixtures is the time to show it.










