Man City News Now | Get Latest Man City Football News

Man City’s Argentine playmaker ends a 191-day wait at Benfica, and a €21m permanent move now looks a matter of time

Claudio Echeverri

Claudio Echeverri has finally started a league game again, and the Manchester City playmaker now looks well on his way to a permanent €21m (£17.5m) move to Benfica.

The 20-year-old Argentine had waited 191 days for a league start. It came in Benfica’s November win over Estrela, his first league start for the Eagles and his first anywhere since 1 May, when he was still on loan at Girona.

According to the Manchester Evening News, the likelihood now is that Benfica will take up their €21m option to sign him for good at the end of the season. After three loans in 12 months, this one finally looks like the right fit.

Why a league start matters so much

It sounds small, but for Echeverri it is a big deal. He has been a regular in Benfica’s matchday squads since arriving in September and has started in the Europa League, but the league had kept him waiting until the Estrela game.

He has made seven appearances in all competitions so far. That is not a huge number, yet it has been enough to show Benfica boss Marco Silva that he can add something to the side. We wrote earlier this month that Echeverri had finally found the right loan, and a first league start backs that up.

Three loans in twelve months

The road to Lisbon has been a bumpy one. At the start of last season Echeverri turned down City’s plan to send him to Girona for the whole campaign. He chose a loan at Bayer Leverkusen instead, and it did not work out, so the move was cut short in January.

He then went to Girona after all, but that spell ended with cameo appearances off the bench as City’s sister club were relegated to the second tier. Benfica in September was his third loan in 12 months, and he badly needed this one to go well.

Not every young City player sent abroad goes the same way. Vitor Reis was tracked closely during his La Liga loan and has since opened his account for City, while Echeverri’s future now seems to lie away from Manchester.

What has Marco Silva said about Echeverri?

Silva has not confirmed that Benfica will trigger the option, but he has spoken warmly about how much Echeverri has improved since he arrived. Speaking last month, the Benfica coach made it clear that quality was never the question.

He said: “I’d say we have plenty of time to assess him and integrate him into the team. And I’m not talking about quality. Because he’s got plenty of quality. If he didn’t, we wouldn’t have made that move (signing him) so close to the end of the window.”

Silva added that he had asked the board for a player with that profile and that he knew Echeverri well from his short time in England. “The player knows we’re pleased with him; we know the talent we have in the squad to work with. He has to keep working, and work hard,” he said, before stressing that Benfica would make the decision “at the right time” and in the club’s best interests.

Does Echeverri want to stay at Benfica?

It certainly sounds that way. Asked about becoming a permanent Benfica player, Echeverri said: “One step at a time, we’ll see what happens. Still, it would be wonderful.”

How it went wrong for Echeverri at Man City

City signed Echeverri from River Plate in 2024 for £12.5m, and he went straight back to Argentina on loan. He caught the eye at the Club World Cup, but his City career never kicked on from there.

Pep Guardiola took a swipe at the player’s representatives, and Echeverri was soon shipped out on loan. City always saw him as a player with first-team potential, and he has shown glimpses of why, but he now looks likely to leave next summer.

Verdict: a €21m Echeverri sale is the sensible ending

On the money alone, City would turn a £12.5m signing into a sale of around £17.5m, and that is before you count what the add-ons we reported earlier could bring. For a player who has spent almost his whole time as a City player somewhere else, that is decent business.

More importantly, it looks right for the player. Echeverri has had a public swipe at his representatives from Guardiola, a German loan that fell apart and a relegation in Spain. At Benfica he has a coach who asked for his profile, a first league start and a club that clearly rate him. Sometimes the best thing a big club can do for a talented 20-year-old is let him go, and this is one of those times.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To Top