Joe Hart has backed Gianluigi Donnarumma to come good at Man City, but the former Blues number one wants the Italian to stop trying to do everything and get back to being the keeper who simply dares strikers to beat him.
Gianluigi Donnarumma has had a rough few weeks between the sticks, and the noise around him has only grown during the international break. We’ve already heard Steph Houghton argue that Maresca’s changing back four is hurting the Italian goalkeeper, and now another familiar Etihad voice has had his say.
Hart knows the spotlight better than most. He had a superb career at City until Pep Guardiola axed him, and he is convinced Donnarumma is still the right man for the job. What he wants is calm, and the basics done well.
What did Joe Hart say about Donnarumma?
Speaking on the latest episode of the Overlap Fan Debate, Hart described the Italian as going through “a real human stage at the moment”, and was quick to add that he wasn’t simply defending him. “At the moment, he’s not saving the balls that he expects to save,” he said.
He pointed to the goal against Paris Saint-Germain as the perfect example of how thin the line is for a keeper. “What a brilliant save by Donnarumma, and then it lands and then goes in, and it’s gone from being a brilliant save to a horrendous mistake,” Hart said. “If it’s a brilliant save, it’s a shot that maybe you shouldn’t, and it goes in, all of a sudden he’s the worst goalie in the world.”
Not set, not quick, and trying too hard
The follow-up, the goal Nicolas Jackson scored past him, was a different matter. Hart put that down to “little technical errors, not quite being set”, and he was blunt about why that matters so much for this particular keeper.
“Donnarumma, for example, is not a quick goalie, that’s not his skill. David Raya, really quick. Donnarumma is about being stood there in a decent-ish position and going, ‘I’ve got the wingspan to save anything here. Come at me,'” he explained.
His diagnosis is that Donnarumma has started looking for ways to help his team, coming for things he shouldn’t. “We’ve all been in those moments where your usual high level is not being attained, and you start looking for a little bit. He just needs a little calming moment,” Hart said. “He needs to be given a chance because he deserves a chance. The club have invested in him. He’s made match-winning saves.”
The saves that still count
Hart was keen not to let the mistakes wipe out the good bits. Donnarumma’s big stop at Old Trafford helped City see out a 1-0 win over Manchester United, and Hart also pointed to his last-minute heroics at Liverpool.
“I think he’s got people off their feet who don’t even like goalies, in games that he’s won with last-minute saves,” he said. “But he’s having a moment. But it’s hard to have a moment when the team’s a little bit fragile in front of you.”
That last line matters. The debate over City’s goalkeeper has also been fed by events elsewhere, with James Trafford’s display for England in Madrid reopening the question of whether City sold the wrong man.
Verdict: Donnarumma needs fewer jobs, not more
Hart’s message is simple, and it is the right one. “You don’t need to be a hybrid goalie. You need to make the simple passes, have the understanding as a goalkeeper who you pass to, who you don’t pass to, and when you’re in trouble, getting rid of it,” he said. “I need Donnarumma standing there and saying, ‘Come beat me.’ So if he can get back to that, he’ll be absolutely fine.”
For us, that is exactly where Maresca has to meet him halfway. Donnarumma was never bought to be a sweeper who plays out like a sixth defender. He was bought for the saves Hart is talking about, and a settled back line in front of him would let him get back to making them. Strip the job down, let him plant his feet, and the keeper who won games at Liverpool and Old Trafford should not be far away.











