Analysis

‘The players do take that inch’: Man City cult hero says Guardiola’s exit is behind the slump of City’s England centre-back and Italian keeper

Gianluigi Donnarumma joins Manchester City

Richard Dunne thinks he knows why Marc Guehi and Gianluigi Donnarumma have gone from Manchester City’s safest pair to the faces of a three-game losing run: Pep Guardiola is not there any more to stop the players taking an inch.

The City cult hero has given one of the bluntest verdicts yet on what has gone wrong at the back under Enzo Maresca. City won their first seven Premier League games, then lost to Aston Villa, Brighton and Nottingham Forest, and they go into Saturday’s game against Fulham third in the table, six points behind Arsenal.

Dunne does not think it is one player. He thinks it is a chain: a mistake in midfield, a defender a yard slower than last season, and a goalkeeper who is no longer bailing everybody out.

What has gone wrong with Marc Guehi?

The England centre-back was one of the most reliable defenders in the league, and this autumn he has made mistakes that have been punished. Dunne thinks the league has changed around him. Teams used to back off and let City’s defenders have the ball. Now they press the moment it arrives at Marc Guehi‘s feet.

He said: “I think the whole Premier League has changed in terms of going back three or four years, teams would let Man City’s defence have the ball and they’d back off, whereas now as soon as Guehi’s receiving it, he’s under pressure. Teams are pressing higher, they’re getting more physical with them and the game’s getting quicker, so mistakes are highlighted even more and then it comes down to confidence.”

Then the part every defender will recognise: “You make one or two mistakes and then the next time the ball comes to you it’s ‘I hope my touch is good’ instead of it just being a natural process. You start to overthink situations and that’s probably where Guehi is and not just him, but the defence in general has been this season.”

Guehi may not even be available on Saturday. He came off at the City Ground with a hip problem and then withdrew from the England squad, and we looked at the knock-on effect in Maresca’s back-four puzzle before the break. Maresca speaks to the media on Friday, so that should settle it.

Donnarumma’s save rate is “too low”

Dunne was even firmer on the goalkeeper. Donnarumma’s save percentage has dropped to 65 per cent, and when asked whether City should expect more, he did not hesitate.

“100%. It’s too low. Regardless of whether they’re taking more shots or not, the fact that his actual save percentage has dropped isn’t good. You can see it. You can see the goals that are going in. We’re all looking at it thinking, ‘he would have saved that last year, it would have been better’.”

He also explained why a goalkeeper’s form spreads: “If you’ve got a goalkeeper who’s making errors, then your defenders start to think ‘well, I can’t make an error’, and that adds a little bit of pressure and it spreads throughout the whole team.” And on the Italian himself: “He seems to have dropped off a little bit. He’s not getting down as quick as he was.”

Maresca has stood by him all along. In October he summed up his view as “in this moment it’s Gigio plus 10”, and Joe Hart has also backed City’s keeper to come through it, with one big change to his game.

Saved Italy from six?

The international break showed both sides of him. Italy beat France and then went to Brussels and lost 4-1 to Belgium, a result that dropped them from first to third in their Nations League group. City’s Jeremy Doku was among Belgium’s scorers.

And yet the Belgium boss Mark van Bommel came away praising the man who let in four. He told Sky Sport Italia: “If Donnarumma had not been in goal, then we would’ve scored six.”

That is the strange thing about Donnarumma right now. He can still make the saves that make an opposition manager shake his head. What Dunne is pointing at is the ones he used to make as a matter of routine.

The Guardiola effect

Dunne’s conclusion is the one City will least like hearing, because it is the one Maresca can do least about. “It’s just everything. It’s the effect of not having Pep Guardiola there. I know Maresca has come in and done really well, but when you’ve got one of the world’s best managers who doesn’t allow an inch and then he’s gone, the players do take that inch and it responds in the performances.”

He is not writing Maresca off, and neither are we. Seven straight wins to start a season does not happen by accident. But the defenders and the keeper who looked untouchable under Pep Guardiola have not looked the same for a month.

Verdict: Donnarumma and Guehi need one clean afternoon

Dunne is right that confidence is the whole story here. A centre-back who is thinking about his first touch and a keeper a fraction slow to get down are both problems that a couple of calm games can fix, and that a couple more bad ones can make much worse.

Fulham at home is the right place to start. City have not failed to beat them at the Etihad in nearly 16 years, and our Man City vs Fulham preview has the full team news. A first clean sheet in ten games would do more for Donnarumma and whoever plays at centre-back than any number of pundits defending them, with Napoli on Tuesday and Arsenal away on 29 November.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To Top