Nico O’Reilly won the PFA Young Player of the Year award in August, but three months later he has started only four Premier League games for Manchester City, and the international break was spent getting his back right rather than playing for England.
Enzo Maresca did not list him among the doubts for Saturday’s visit of Fulham, which means the 21-year-old should be available again. The question now is whether he walks straight back into the side at left-back, or whether Josko Gvardiol keeps the shirt.
It is a big call for a defence that has conceded 17 goals in its last eight games in all competitions, and one that says a lot about how Maresca sees his best back four.
What happened to Nico O’Reilly this season?
Last season was the breakthrough. Nico O’Reilly made 29 Premier League starts, scored five goals and added three assists, and was named the Premier League’s Young Player of the Season in May before the players voted him PFA Young Player of the Year. He was also in the PFA Premier League Team of the Year.
This season has been stop-start. He has eight league appearances, but only four of them are starts, with no goals or assists from seven shots. The reason is a back problem that has been with him since before the Coventry game early in the season.
Maresca explained it plainly at his press conference on 6 November, the day before Forest and the same day O’Reilly was left out of Thomas Tuchel’s England squad. “Since we started the season, his back [problem], if you remember, before the Coventry game. Some more problems, unfortunately. He’s not 100%,” he said.
“This is what we need from Nico”
The same answer also showed how much Maresca rates him. “In the last game, I really liked him, he was playing a very good game. This is what we need from Nico; just keep him fit because we know how good he is. And no doubt that in the future he will be again with the international team,” he said.
That last game was the 3-2 win in Leipzig, which O’Reilly started. Three days later he was on the bench at the City Ground and came on in the 3-1 defeat. Then came the plan for the break: “The break is what he needs, to use the break to do the right things in terms of therapy and these kind of things, and be 100% after the international break.”
Nico O’Reilly or Gvardiol at left-back?
This is where it gets interesting. Gvardiol has filled in on the left all season and has done it well going forward. He has three league assists from left-back, as many as any City player, plus a goal. But he was robbed for Forest’s opening goal after six minutes, and after a small issue in the week before that game, he was taken off at half-time.
Gvardiol then played for Croatia during the break, so he is fit and match-sharp. O’Reilly is fresh but has had two weeks of therapy rather than football. On form, Gvardiol has the edge. On what Maresca has said about O’Reilly, the young Englishman is the one he wants.
There is a third factor. With Abdukodir Khusanov and Matheus Nunes both listed as doubts on Friday, as we covered in Maresca’s pre-Fulham press conference, Gvardiol may be needed in the middle or Maresca may want him as cover there. Using O’Reilly at left-back would keep Gvardiol free for that job, as we set out in our look at City’s centre-back options.
Where does Rayan Aït-Nouri fit?
Further down the list. The Algerian has three assists in only 168 minutes this season, none of them in the league, and has been linked with a loan away in January. As we argued in our look at his difficult start, O’Reilly earned his place and Gvardiol is Gvardiol.
What O’Reilly brings against Fulham
Fulham like to push the ball wide quickly, and Alex Iwobi is their main creator from the left, which puts him on City’s right rather than O’Reilly’s side. On O’Reilly’s flank, Fulham are likely to have Oscar Bobb, another City academy graduate, who knows exactly how O’Reilly plays.
Five league goals from a full-back last season is a rare return, and that is the part of his game City have missed. Against a Fulham side that has not conceded from a corner all season, City need goals from open play, and a 6ft 4in left-back who can arrive in the box is a useful extra weapon.
We picked him at left-back in our Man City predicted lineup vs Fulham, and nothing from Friday changes that view.
Verdict: a fit Nico O’Reilly starts
Our view: if his back is right, O’Reilly should start on Saturday. Maresca has said it himself: City need him fit because they know how good he is. Gvardiol has been a good stand-in, but City’s defensive problems have not been about the left-back going forward, they have been about mistakes, and a settled back four with Gvardiol available as cover makes more sense than another reshuffle.
The bigger test comes after that. Napoli visit on Tuesday and Arsenal are next weekend. If O’Reilly gets through Fulham without a reaction, City have their PFA Young Player of the Year back at the right time.











