Manchester City have more of the ball than anyone in the Premier League and create better chances than anyone too, but the gap Fulham will try to run through on Saturday is the one between Elliot Anderson and his own back four.
City average 65.5% possession, the highest in the division, and their 21 league goals are the second most, from the highest expected goals total in the league at 20.1. On the ball, the Enzo Maresca project is doing what it was hired to do.
The problem is what happens when the ball is lost. Three straight league defeats before the international break all had the same thread, and Fulham arrive at the Etihad for the 12.30pm UK kick-off as one of the few sides in the league built to exploit it from both ends.
How Maresca’s City set up with the ball
Far from moving away from the Guardiola model, City doubled down on it when they appointed his former assistant. The play is patient and expansive, built on technical players who are comfortable in tight central spaces and whose job is to find Erling Haaland.
In possession Maresca’s side shape up as a 3-1-6. Elliot Anderson sits alone at the base, the other midfielders push on, and the width comes from wingers who can carry the ball past a narrow block: Jeremy Doku and Iliman Ndiaye now, with Antoine Semenyo to come back later in the season.
It explains why City have so many shots. It also explains where the trouble starts.
Why are Man City conceding on the counter?
Because when the ball goes, there is often only one midfielder left in the middle. With the other central players already high up the pitch, a turnover sends opponents straight into the space in front of the centre-backs.
That is not new. In Pep Guardiola’s final season, City gave up 39 fast-break shots in the Premier League, the most in the division. Before this international break they had already allowed 19 fast-break shots and conceded four goals that way in all competitions.
The defeat at the City Ground was the clearest example. Errors in the build-up and cheap giveaways in the final third were punished by a side who wanted City to have the ball, and as Oliver Glasner explained afterwards in Forest’s plan to beat Man City, that was the whole idea.
Is it the players or the system?
This is the question City fans keep asking. If the issue is personnel, the fix is quick: Rayan Cherki is brilliant on the ball but limited without it, and Anderson may simply need a more defensive partner than Enzo Fernandez.
If the issue is the structure itself, and the setup just asks too much of one holding midfielder, it is harder. Maresca has tended to stick with his preferred system at previous clubs, and on Friday he was not in the mood to blame the midfield.
“The same midfield that won seven games in a row is the same midfield that lost three games in a row. It is football,” he said. That is why so many supporters want Ayyoub Bouaddi in for this one, as we found when 74% of fans wanted the £125m signing dropped for Fulham.
Why Fulham are a dangerous opponent for this City side
Fulham are the team closest to City in the way they play. Under Alvaro Arbeloa they build long passing moves to pull opponents out of shape, and they average 572 passes a game, the third most in the league.
That matters for two reasons. First, they will not simply sit in a low block and wait, so City cannot assume they will have the ball in safe areas. Second, a side that is comfortable passing through pressure is exactly the kind that can turn a City giveaway into a quick break through the middle.
Arbeloa said as much in his own press conference: Fulham will press and run. With Fulham unbeaten in four league games, they will believe it.
Elliot Anderson is the key man
Everything comes back to the No.6. Replacing Rodri was never going to be easy, yet Anderson has been leading City’s midfielders in both ball-winning actions and line-breaking passes this season, by an even bigger margin than the Spaniard used to.
The debate over whether he is a true lone holding midfielder, or better with a little more freedom, runs on. Our Elliot Anderson scouting report found that rivals have learned to drag him out of position, and Fulham’s double pivot of Sander Berge and Shea Charles will be asked to do exactly that.
If Anderson is left alone with Berge and Charles running beyond him, City are open. If he has someone next to him who protects the space, City’s possession numbers should do the rest.
Verdict: one change in midfield, not a new system
Our view: Maresca does not need to tear up his plan, but he does need to give Anderson help. City are scoring, creating and controlling games, and that is not something to throw away after three bad results.
What has to change is the cover. Start a midfielder alongside Anderson who thinks about the ball being lost before it is lost, keep the full-backs honest, and the Fulham counter is far less frightening. Leave him alone again, and a Fulham side that already knows where to aim could end a run of 20 straight defeats against City.











