Man City News Now | Get Latest Man City Football News

$2bn loan scrapped at the final stage, as the 115 charges finally cost Man City’s owners real money

Etihad Stadium 2018

Manchester City’s owners have lost a $2billion (£1.25bn) loan because of the Premier League charges, with the lender walking away just as the deal was reaching the finish line.

According to the Financial Times, Apollo Global Management pulled out of the agreement with the City Football Group after the independent commission ruled that the club had broken the Premier League’s financial rules. The two sides were said to be in the final stages of negotiations when the US private capital firm stepped back.

It is the first hard, measurable cost of the verdict, and it lands before City have even had their appeal heard.

Why did Apollo walk away from the Man City loan?

The timing tells the story. Apollo withdrew once it was announced that City had artificially inflated their finances by more than £900m over nine years through what the commission called “sham” contracts. The panel found the club guilty of all but one of the 115 charges, covering breaches between 2009 and 2018.

The collapse of the deal is said to reflect the uncertainty that now hangs over the club: nobody yet knows how far any sanction will go, and the possible outcomes run from a fine all the way to a points deduction. For a lender, that is a risk with no ceiling, and Apollo clearly did not want to price it.

City have pleaded their innocence from the start and lodged a formal appeal at the turn of October. We covered the timetable when it emerged that the appeal against the verdict will be heard in December, with any punishment not landing until 2027, and a decision on the appeal is now expected around the turn of the year.

Who are Apollo Global Management?

Apollo are no strangers to football money. The firm has been at the front of the recent wave of investment into sport: last year it agreed to buy a majority stake in Atletico Madrid, and it then financed a $2.6bn deal for the holding company of the New York Yankees.

Closer to home, Apollo loaned £80m to Nottingham Forest in December 2024. So this is not a lender nervous about football in general. It is a lender nervous about City in particular, which is exactly why the decision stings.

What would the $2bn have meant for City?

Had the deal gone through, it would have given Sheikh Mansour more room to back the club while the case drags on. Instead, the Blues’ owners go into the appeal without that extra financial cushion.

The Man City charges fallout is spreading

The loan is not the only knock-on effect. Within 24 hours of the guilty verdict, Etihad Airways, one of City’s main sponsors, said it was considering legal action against the Premier League. The airline complained that the verdict suggested it had been involved in “improper commercial arrangements”, which it rejects, and claimed the league had not contacted it during the hearing.

Etisalat followed with a statement of its own on Monday:

“Emirates Telecommunications Group Company PJSC [Etisalat] views the published findings of the English Premier League, as they relate to Etisalat, as entirely false and defamatory.”

“Etisalat is actively considering all options relating to its rights and associated legal remedies in this matter,” it added.

Why the Premier League wants its clubs to pay

A corporate defamation case could cost billions, and that is why the league has gone to its clubs for help. Chief executive Richard Masters and fellow board members Alison Brittain, Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder KC do not hold legal indemnity against third parties such as club sponsors.

As we explained earlier this week, the Premier League has asked every club to cover Masters and the board if City’s sponsors sue. A two-page proposal went to the clubs ahead of a meeting in London on Thursday, and at least 14 of the 20 must agree for it to pass. The document does not mention City, their sponsors or the charges case as the reason for the protection.

What punishment could City face?

Nothing is set in stone, and that is the whole problem. Some fans and pundits want City relegated from the Premier League and stripped of every title won in the nine-year period. Others think a points deduction and a transfer embargo would be enough.

The wait has already frustrated plenty of people, even if one integrity chief insists the slow pace is not down to a “lazy” panel.

Verdict: the charges are now costing City real money

Until now, the 115 charges have mostly been a fight over words, rulings and reputations. A $2bn loan disappearing at the final stage turns it into something City’s owners can count.

The bigger worry is the message it sends. If one of the most active investors in football will not lend against City while the appeal is open, others may take the same view, and that uncertainty does not end until the appeal is decided around the turn of the year. Until then, every sponsor statement and every board vote adds to the noise around the Etihad, and the club will hope the football can stay apart from it.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To Top