Enzo Maresca left his £125m club record signing on the bench against Fulham, and the midfielder who replaced him in the plan, Elliot Anderson, produced the best individual display of a miserable afternoon and his first Premier League goal for Manchester City.
The 1-1 draw at the Etihad was a fourth league game without a win, and City were booed off. But if anything useful came out of Saturday, it was a clearer picture of how Maresca’s £327m midfield should fit together.
City spent that money on three players in the summer: Enzo Fernandez, Anderson and Ayyoub Bouaddi. Against Fulham, for the first time in a while, it was the Anderson and Bouaddi pairing that started, and the difference in Anderson’s game was obvious.
Why was Enzo Fernandez dropped against Fulham?
Maresca made three changes from the 3-1 defeat at Nottingham Forest, and leaving out Fernandez was the one that raised eyebrows. The Argentine had made a 14,000-mile round trip to Buenos Aires during the international break for Argentina’s friendlies against Uruguay and Costa Rica.
Maresca did not give the travel as a reason. “I just think for this game it’s better having Ayyoub Bouaddi in there,” he told TNT Sports shortly before kick-off. On Friday he had said he was looking for “more balance” in the “defensive line, midfield and up front”, and that City had “won games with Enzo and lost games with Enzo”.
Fernandez got the final five minutes in place of Bouaddi. It was a clear message about who Maresca trusted to start a game City badly needed to win.
What Bouaddi’s presence does for Anderson
The key is the job each man is given. When Fernandez plays, Elliot Anderson tends to sit in front of the back four. With the 19-year-old Moroccan Bouaddi beside him, starting only his third Premier League game, Anderson had the licence to roam, and he used it.
The numbers tell the story:
- His first Premier League goal for City, a first-time volley from outside the box after David Affengruber headed a corner clear
- Three chances created, the most of any player on the pitch
- 16 passes in the final third, all of them completed
- Seven touches in the Fulham box, more than anyone else
- 17 duels contested and more recoveries than any other player
- Four shots, level with Erling Haaland for the most in the game
Fulham could not cope with him. Alex Iwobi and Shea Charles were both booked for fouling him, and soon after his equaliser another shot from a Haaland cut-back rolled just wide of the far post. Not bad for a player whose international break ended with a red card for England against Spain.
Maresca saw it too. “Ayyoub with Elliot were both really good,” he said after the game. “Today we used Elliot a bit more attacking midfielder, he arrived inside the box and scored a fantastic goal, he had three or four moments around the box where he was really dangerous.
“It is another solution for us. In this moment, we are trying to know each other more as players and also to find the right solution.”
Bouaddi did his part as well
Bouaddi’s job was less eye-catching but just as important. He gives City more insurance in front of the defence and keeps the ball moving, and in the second half he was one of the few City players willing to drive the team forward. It was not a perfect day for the midfield, though: Anderson could not stop Oscar Bobb in the move that led to Rodrigo Muniz’s opener, a goal that started from a Fulham throw-in deep in their own half. Our full report on the 1-1 draw with Fulham has how the rest of the afternoon unfolded.
Did Cherki’s arrival limit Anderson?
City still could not find a winner, and the substitution after 70 minutes is the part of the afternoon worth questioning. Rayan Cherki came on for Phil Foden, took up the space around the box that Anderson had been using, and Anderson had to drop back down the pitch.
Former City goalkeeper Joe Hart made that point to BBC Sport. “It felt like Elliot Anderson was going to take the game by the scruff of the neck but then Cherki came on and took his position. So he [Anderson] didn’t have as much of an impact on the game,” he said.
“I understood the change, when the lines are deep, there were chances of Cherki unlocking Fulham, but they just defended so well and they also offered a threat on the break.”
That threat on the break is the same one we flagged before the game in our look at the fast breaks City keep conceding. Fulham had only four shots, but every one of them was on target.
So where does Fernandez fit now?
This is Maresca’s problem for the next week. The No.10 role belongs to Cherki or Foden. If Bouaddi is the steady one and Anderson the one who breaks forward, the £125m man has no obvious place in the side.
Hart thinks rotation is simply part of the job at a club like City. “There is no point in having a brilliant squad like Manchester City if you are not going to take that into account,” he said. “If someone’s done the travelling, he has done the game time, you have got to expect to not use him as much.”
Verdict: build the midfield around Elliot Anderson
Our view is simple. Anderson has to be the player City’s midfield is built around, and the other two spots should be picked to suit him, not the other way round. On Saturday he was the one City player who looked at the level the club needs, and he did it in a role that let him attack.
That does not mean Fernandez is finished. Napoli come to the Etihad on Tuesday and Arsenal wait at the Emirates next Sunday, so there will be minutes for everyone. But for the Arsenal game in particular, we would start Bouaddi and Anderson together again, and let Fernandez prove from the bench that he can fit around them.











