Analysis

Set up Kane, then sent off in Madrid: Man City’s £116m midfielder showed Maresca his best and worst in one night

Enzo-Maresca-Man-City.

Elliot Anderson played the pass that opened the scoring for England in Madrid, then saw red for the foul that gave Spain a way back. It was the best and the worst of Man City’s £116m midfielder in one night, and it is the same story Enzo Maresca has been watching at the Etihad.

England still won 3-2 to end Spain’s 43-game unbeaten run and top their Nations League group, and Thomas Tuchel called it the best performance of his time in charge. But the red card changed the game, and for City the more useful question is what it says about the player they rely on more than any other in midfield.

Anderson is available for Fulham at the Etihad on Saturday. Here is our look at what Madrid showed, good and bad, and what it means for Maresca.

What happened to Elliot Anderson against Spain?

For an hour, Anderson was part of an England side that took the world champions apart. England pressed high, ran at Spain and gave them nothing.

The opener came from him. Just before half-time, Anderson played a first-time pass inside to Harry Kane, who shielded the ball from Pau Cubarsí and was clipped for a penalty. There was a long VAR check on Anderson’s follow-through before it was given, and Kane scored low into the corner. Ezri Konsa and Ben White then made it 3-0 early in the second half.

Then it turned. Jarell Quansah was robbed by Lamine Yamal as the last man, and Anderson, coming across to cover, pulled the winger back in the box. Red card, penalty, and Mikel Oyarzabal scored. Moments later Nico Williams made it 3-2, and England spent the last half-hour hanging on, with James Trafford making save after save.

Tuchel did not hide what the sending-off did to his side. “Of course, the red card and the penalty changed the momentum and the characteristic of the game and 30 minutes against Spain in Spain feels like three hours so that changed everything,” he said.

Was the red card his fault?

Only partly. The mistake that started it was Quansah’s, and Anderson was the one left to deal with Lamine Yamal running clear. Plenty of midfielders would have made the same choice in that split second.

But it fits a pattern. The same instinct that makes Anderson so good at winning the ball also pulls him into challenges he does not need to make. A Premier League panel ruled that he should have given away a penalty at Villa Park last month, when he stepped across Johan Manzambi rather than playing the ball. In our Elliot Anderson scouting report we pointed out how Sunderland, Paris St-Germain and Brighton have all used decoy runs to drag him out of the middle. Madrid was another version of the same thing: a player trying to fix everything himself.

Why Man City need Anderson more than ever

None of this changes how important he is. Elliot Anderson was the first signing of Maresca’s reign, arriving from Nottingham Forest for £116m, and since Rodri left for Barcelona the job of protecting City’s back four has fallen mostly on him.

His numbers back that up. Going into the Forest game, he was first in the Premier League for fouls drawn, second for duels won and third for both successful passes and touches. Maresca has called him “a dream for a manager”, and before that return to the City Ground he made it clear that he sees even more in him. “For me in this moment, Elliot is playing more as the holding midfielder, but in future, no doubt that he can play also a little bit more up front,” he said, as we reported in Maresca’s comments on Anderson’s Forest return.

The problem is that he is doing it alone

City lost three league games in a row before the break, to Aston Villa, Brighton and Forest, and conceded early in each of them. Too often Anderson has been the only man screening the defence, so when he jumps out to press or follows a runner, there is nobody behind him.

That is the real lesson from Madrid. In a side that had control for an hour, Anderson was excellent. When the game broke up and he was the last line, he made the wrong call. City cannot keep asking him to be both.

Who plays next to Elliot Anderson against Fulham?

This is the call that matters most on Saturday. Maresca has named Anderson, Ayyoub Bouaddi, Enzo Fernandez, Rayan Cherki, Phil Foden and Mateo Kovacic as his midfield options, and has picked the shape game by game.

We think Bouaddi should start alongside him. He is a natural holding midfielder, and with him next to Anderson there is a second body in the middle when the Englishman steps out. We made the full case in our Man City predicted lineup vs Fulham, and in our piece on whether Enzo Fernandez should be dropped. Madrid only makes that argument stronger.

Elliot Anderson verdict: more help, not less Anderson

A red card for England is not a reason to worry about Anderson. He had a big hand in a famous win, and he has been City’s most reliable midfielder in a difficult autumn.

My view: the fault in his game is the fault of a player who cares too much about winning the ball back, and that is fixable. Maresca’s part is to stop leaving him on his own. Give Anderson a partner who holds the middle, and City get the player who set up Kane in Madrid far more often than the one who chased Lamine Yamal back into his own box.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To Top