International

‘What exactly are they holding against him?’ France World Cup winner defends Man City’s playmaker after his man of the match night in Bordeaux

Rayan Cherki Man City

Emmanuel Petit has come out swinging for Rayan Cherki, asking what the critics actually hold against the Man City playmaker after a week in which he went from the San Siro fallout to man of the match in Bordeaux.

The 1998 World Cup winner spoke on RMC after France finished the November break on top of their Nations League group. Rayan Cherki, 23, now has 20 senior caps and three goals for his country, and he has become a regular under Zinedine Zidane after spending most of the Didier Deschamps years on the fringes.

That has not stopped him being the first name blamed when France have a bad night. Petit thinks that is unfair, and he named the players he would look at first.

What did Petit say about Cherki?

Petit’s point was that the scrutiny has followed Cherki since the start of his career and never really stopped. “I’ve been hearing the constant criticism directed at Cherki for some time now,” he said. “What exactly are they holding against him?”

He also pointed out how often Cherki gets the ball with his back to goal and has to sort the situation out on his own, which is not the easiest way to look good in a France shirt full of runners.

Then came the numbers argument. “Despite everything, he is the second most effective player under the Zidane era, trailing only Olise,” Petit said. Only Michael Olise has done more in attack since Zidane took over, which is quite a thing to say about a player many in France still treat as a luxury.

Who does Petit blame instead?

Not Cherki. Petit went through the side and found plenty of others to question. “I didn’t see [Adrien] Rabiot or [Lucas] Da Cunha winning the ball back,” he said, adding that the defenders were losing their duels too.

The attackers did not escape either. “I didn’t see Olise and Mbappe tracking back in the defensive transition,” Petit said. “There are lots of players before Cherki who can be criticised.”

From the San Siro to man of the match in Bordeaux

The timing of the defence makes sense. Cherki left Milan with a dark look after France lost 3-1 to Italy, their first defeat under Zidane, and the stories about a row with Bradley Barcola grew bigger by the day. We looked at what was really said in our piece on the Cherki and Barcola bust-up claims.

Three days later he answered on the pitch. France beat Türkiye 2-1 at the Stade Atlantique on Sunday, and Cherki was involved in both goals. His corner led to the opener three minutes after half-time, when Adrien Rabiot’s near-post header went in off Emirhan Topcu. Ten minutes from time, he combined with debutant Junior Kroupi, who slid in for his first international goal.

Abdulkerim Bardakci pulled one back in the 90th minute, but France held on to finish top of League A Group 1 and go through to the quarter-finals. Cherki was named man of the match.

What it means for Man City and Fulham

City need that version of him back at the Etihad. Enzo Maresca’s side went into the break on a run of three straight league defeats, and Cherki was the one bright spark in the 3-1 loss at the City Ground, as our player ratings from the Forest defeat made clear.

Next up is Fulham at home on Saturday, 21 November. Cherki comes back from France with a man of the match award, a group won and a World Cup winner fighting his corner, which is about as good a week as an international break can give a player who was being written off a few days earlier. Our guide to City’s internationals shows how the rest of the squad’s games were spread out.

Verdict: Petit is right about Cherki

Cherki will always split opinion because of the way he plays. He wants the ball in tight spaces, he tries the difficult pass and sometimes it does not come off. That makes him an easy target when France lose, and much less so when they win, as Sunday showed.

But Petit’s list is the fair one. When midfielders are not winning the ball back and the forwards are not running back, a number ten with his back to goal is the wrong man to single out. If Maresca can get the Bordeaux Cherki rather than the Milan one against Fulham, City’s slump could end sooner than people think.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To Top