Premier League clubs have voted to cover the league’s legal costs if Manchester City’s sponsors sue its board members personally, and City were among the clubs who voted against it.
The decision means chief executive Richard Masters, chair Alison Brittain and the three non-executive directors, Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder, will be financially protected if a corporate defamation case is brought against any of them as individuals.
According to The Athletic, club owners and executives met in London on Thursday to vote on the request. It was their first meeting since September, when an independent commission found City guilty of artificially inflating their revenue through what it called “sham” contracts with sponsors.
Who voted against protecting Masters?
The first report said only one club opposed the motion. Other reports since have named two: City themselves and Nottingham Forest, with the other 18 clubs voting in favour.
City voting no was always going to happen. The club would hardly sign up to pay the legal bills of the people who brought the case against it. Forest are the more interesting name. Either way, 18 votes was comfortably more than the 14 the motion needed to pass.
We explained earlier this week why the league asked every club to cover Masters if City’s sponsors sue. The fear is that sponsors such as Etihad Airways, who said in October that they were considering legal action, could go after the directors as individuals, not just the league as a company.
What Masters said when City were found guilty
When the verdict landed in September, Masters said City had “systematically broken Premier League rules for nearly a decade”.
He added: “It is a key responsibility of the Premier League to ensure that the Rules, approved by the clubs themselves, are upheld to protect the integrity of the competition. It is paramount that the League remains competitive and fair for all clubs and for the fans. We take that role extremely seriously. This disciplinary case, and this decision, are the most significant in Premier League history.”
City answered that they were “both disappointed and surprised” by the commission’s opinion. The club said: “The club is innocent of the accusations made by the Premier League and a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence exists in support of all of its positions, relating to this case.”
The statement went on to say City would be “relentless, and where necessary proactive, in any and all appropriate regulatory and legal forums”, and that the opinion “contains clear material errors, of law, principle and fact, and is unsafe”.
When will the Man City appeal be decided?
City lodged their appeal at the start of October. Under a rule brought in this summer, the process should be finished within 12 weeks, with a verdict announced within the 30 days after that, which points to January or February. As we covered last week, the appeal is due to be heard in December, with any punishment not landing until 2027.
The cost of the verdict is already showing up elsewhere. On Thursday we reported that a $2bn loan for City’s owners was scrapped at the final stage because of the uncertainty the charges have created.
Verdict: the sponsors now hold the next move
This vote does not change anything about City’s appeal, but it does clear the way for the league. With its directors covered, there is less reason for the Premier League to hold back the full written judgment, and that document is what Etihad and the other sponsors are said to be waiting for before deciding whether to go to court.
For Enzo Maresca and his players, the focus has to stay on Fulham at the Etihad on Saturday lunchtime. Off the pitch, though, an 18-2 vote says plenty about where the rest of the league stands, and City should expect that fight to get louder once the judgment is published.











